andy warner Arizona Mystery House Auroville Books Bunleau Sulilat Chronicle Books Comics comics for kids Dean Kamen Fordlandia Freetown Christiana Henry Ford History History Comics John Humphrey Noyes Kids' comics Leicester Hemingway Lesbians of the Van Dykes LGBTQ Liberland New Atlantis non-fiction comics North Dumpling Island Oneida NY Oyotungi African Village Palmanova Principality of Hutt River Ra Paulette Reviews Sala Keoku Sealand Segway Sofie Louise Dam Tama-Re Temples of Humankind Thunder Mountain Monument Xieng Khuan

INDIE VIEW: ‘This Land Is My Land’ offers do’s and don’ts for creating your own utopia

INDIE VIEW: 'This Land Is My Land' offers do's and don'ts for creating your own utopia

This Land Is My Land
Written by Andy Warner
Illustrated by Sofie Louise Dam
Chronicle Books

If I stated that I used to be a supporter of New England secession, that is perhaps robust, however it’s truthful to say I’m a sympathizer, and I’ve had loads of moments the place my ardour for it rises — no less than in my very own thoughts or on ineffective Fb standing updates. What units me aside from the individuals in This Land Is My Land — and that is little question the identical for loads of others as properly — is that if I even get to the purpose the place I’m laying out in my head the precise plan of how it might work and what it will be like, I keep in mind that every seemingly good answer creates a variety of different issues that you simply didn’t predict.

In secession, although, you’re at the very least seizing one thing that already exists and simply shifting it aside from the factor it initially existed inside. In its give attention to completely new nations, This Land Is My Land maps out efforts to create one thing from nothing — sometimes no techniques, no assets, and no sustainable connection between the individuals concerned in fashioning out these unbiased states. And but you need to admire these mad individuals who got down to make them work. Properly, not all of them, however a minimum of a few of them, as a result of whereas it doesn’t occur typically and it doesn’t occur cleanly, these are the kinds of people that spark change and originality on the earth. Outsider nation builders don’t typically see victory, however they make life extra fascinating.

This Land Is My Land divides into 5 primary varieties, and units about recounting a number of examples of every all through historical past, together with some newer variations. And a few of them can truly be counted as a hit, however spoiler: those that work are sometimes the least difficult efforts.

This Land Is Your Land is a compendium of dreamers, although a few of them are clearly scalawags. Warner and Dam do an excellent job at embracing the eccentricities of those individuals with out making that facet a destructive. In reality, for a lot of of those people, their offbeat conduct and beliefs, and their place on the margins of no matter society they stay in, are their strongest traits. And a few of their oddness does result in a bigger constructive for that society, typically ensuing within the individual not being required to stay on the margins — although typically they select to as a result of that isn’t solely how they’ve been made to stay, however how they select to reside.

Nevertheless it’s in with the ability to transition from present merely as a fringe group to at least one that is ready to formalize and interpret the attraction of its utopian imaginative and prescient to outsiders that appears to result in success most frequently. For example, within the Intentional Communities part, I discover that one requirement of devising and constructing such dominions is an already well-established embrace of being an outsider. This implies well-established life decisions, like these of the pirates of Libertatia or the notably fascinating touring Lesbians of the Van Dykes, for which is identified that a homosexual individual being “out” was greater than sexuality, it was a radical act.

However any outsider stance might be certified as a radical act, not simply sexuality, and teams just like the Van Dykes, or Freetown Christiana in Denmark, a transformed army base which nonetheless exists, might ever progress previous the novel and right into a realm that inspired variety and debate.

That’s additionally the case for Oneida, NY, which nonetheless exists however was as soon as the imaginative and prescient of John Humphrey Noyes, a Christian heretic who believed it was attainable to construct a paradise on Earth. It become an extremely relegated group, famed for its silverware manufacturing, which turned its focus as an alternative of spirituality and paradise following Noyes’ departure. The silverware was in all probability a greater guess.

This Land Is My Land

From ‘Sealand’

Chaos appears to be the inevitable finish to many of those efforts and Sealand was in a continuing state of chaos. It was birthed within the 1960s from enterprising pirate radio dee-jays who commandeered the deserted HMS Fort Roughs in England as a way to counter BBC programming with rock and roll. It became a struggle between two dee-jays, leading to one promptly proclaiming a principality. Spoiler alert: The story doesn’t get any saner after that, frightening a world incident.

However typically issues do work out, like in Auroville in India, which is located round an enormous golden orb and the legacy of guru Sri Aurobindo and his French spouse Mirra Alfassa, who turned often known as the Mom and was the visionary behind the town. The residents of Auroville post-Mom have been much more visionary in that they gave the town a preventing probability by looking for authorities help in its administration, establishing a fringe society with official approval, a uncommon factor certainly. The Temples of Humankind, an intricate underground complicated constructed into the foothills of the Italian Alps, additionally permits vacationers and, like Auroville, enjoys official recognition.

  The Divine Kingdom of Sukrani is an unimaginable success story. An enormous rock backyard in India,  it was constructed by Nek Chand, a Pakistani refugee and former street inspector. Original in a forgotten gorge from reusable rubbish he collected, his venture of 18 years not solely survived authorities threats as soon as it was found and embraced by the group, it turned a sanctioned public park that he was paid to take care of and broaden till his demise in 2015. Typically issues do go proper.

Oyotungi African Village in South Carolina is a little more curious, although it did survive one way or the other. A relic of the Black Nationalism motion, it nonetheless exists. In some methods, it’s like an Afro-Futurist model of Plimoth Plantation, with the village’s tradition borrowing from the Nigerian Oyo Empire presenting extra of an immersive recreation that permits vacationers.

The Principality of Hutt River is a combined success. It was established in Australia in 1970 by 5 households of farmers in protest of presidency laws of wheat farming. The central determine, Leonard Casley, proclaimed himself monarch of the principality to be able to benefit from a loophole within the regulation. The principality nonetheless exists however as a disputed territory. And Palmanova, which started development on the finish of the 16th Century, a venture by the Republic of Venice to create a utopian city-fort specifically designed for harmonious dwelling and efficient army protection, nonetheless exists. It’s not a utopia, although. It’s simply an oddly constructed metropolis.

This Land Is My Land

From ‘Fordlandia’

There are many one-man disasters within the ebook, singular visions by large egos which are fated to fail, typically spectacularly. Henry Ford could be probably the most notable individual to fall sufferer to this drawback. He was clearly very profitable with lots of his ventures and reworked American manufacturing. However his success hinged on his capacity to name the photographs with out dissent. He utilized this technique to his vigorous push of Anti-Semitism and in addition his creation of Fordlandia in Brazil, partly as an try and convey American values to a created group in South America, partly to get cheaper rubber for tires. The dream fell aside amidst riot, however there are nonetheless Brazilians dwelling in Fordlandia. Ford’s historic legacy, in the meantime, has been notably tarnished because of all of the Anti-Semitism.

Different tycoons tried to create their very own variations, however by no means even acquired so far as Ford. Razor magnate King Camp Gillette had plan for a self-contained metropolis in Upstate New York referred to as Metropolis, however by no means obtained it going and spent most his cash on a loopy mansion in Santa Monica. And Peter Thiel was a part of the Seasteading Institute, which didn’t actually go anyplace. Rose Island was an try by a wealthy Italian architect to create a tax dodge by declaring his offshore residence to be an unbiased nation. That lasted a few yr.

Ernest Hemingway, no matter else you may contemplate him, was an enormous thinker, however so was his brother Leicester, who tried exhausting at a literary profession however failed … till Ernest shot himself within the head and Leicester wrote a memoir about him. That earned Leicester a ton of cash to discovered his personal nation and one of many extra fascinating historic oddities within the e-book, New Atlantis, on a 240 square-foot bamboo raft in worldwide waters off the coast of Jamaica, which highlights the truth that micronations require capital — and even with it, the ending of a micronation and its founder may be tragic. No spoilers right here.

There’s additionally the story of Operation Atlantis, which facilities round Ayn Rand fan Werner Stiefel.  He purchased a motel in Saugerties, NY, in 1968 and provided it as a free place to reside for Libertarians who would assist construct a ship destined for the Caribbean with a view to create a “stateless utopia.” A collection of calamities ensued.

After which there’s the bizarre man from Virginia who tried to make his daughter a princess by claiming possession of legally unbiased land between Sudan and Egypt. He wasn’t very organized, although. Comparable is Liberland, a disputed piece of land between Serbia and Croatia that a man named Vit Jedlicka has declared a free republic. Jedlicka’s tried to enter the nation with followers, although Croatian border patrol has to date prevented that from occurring.

It’s moderately gracious to seek advice from Tama-Re as a utopia, failed or not. The land in Georgia was populated by a gaggle led by a Muslim heretic with a number of names who preached about aliens, claimed ancestry to Native American tribes, constructed pyramids and tried to run casinos there, and was usually a con man. I assume it was a utopia to him.

A minimum of there’s the nonetheless present North Dumpling Island is dominated by Segway inventor Dean Kamen, a.okay.a. Lord Dumpling, who looks like he has a humorousness a minimum of.

Many of those efforts revolve round paintings, typically large visions that would by no means be contained in any gallery or museum since they sometimes require vital alteration to the panorama. In the USA, there’s Frank Van Zant’s Thunder Mountain Monument, an enormous work commemorating the Native American genocide. It was briefly a hippie commune, however principally the lonely hang-out of a tragic man.

This Land Is My Land

From ‘Ra Paulette’s Caves’

Extra inspiring is Ra Paulette, who targeted his creativity on digging out caves in sandstone impressed by Mexican youngsters doing the identical. Paulette’s created quite a few caves with intricately lovely carving work on their partitions and continues to take action nicely into his 70s and regardless of accidents.

Some very touching examples seem in Asia. Xieng Khuan and Sala Keoku are tributes to human perseverance and survival, sitting on both sides of the Mekong River, one in Laos and one in Thailand. They’re the work of Bunleau Sulilat who started work on the Laos sculpture throughout a communist insurgency. Fleeing to the opposite aspect of the river, he set about on a companion sculpture backyard that he labored on for 20 years, till his dying. There’s additionally Track Peilun’s Yelang Valley venture, a sprawling and still-in-progress sculpture tribute to the Guizhou tradition which has disappeared since China has modernized.

Swedish artist Lars Vilks has a harder state of affairs, having created the micronation of Ladonia in an effort to save his large outside paintings from the Swedish authorities, however now boasts over 20,000 residents, which any of us can be happy to turn into certainly one of.

The Homosexual and Lesbian Kingdom of the Coral Sea Islands amounted to a hilarious and superb piece of efficiency artwork. It was a protest towards the Australian authorities’s refusal to legalize same-sex marriage that noticed a gaggle of protesters crusing on the Gayflower to an atoll off the Australian coast. Proclaiming an emperor and mechanically making each LBGTQ individual on the earth a citizen, it existed for 10 years.

The Arizona Thriller Citadel is aligned with this artwork designation, however solely simply. It was constructed from one man’s imaginative and prescient in tribute to his daughter, however principally exists as an oddity somewhat than for any high-minded function however the story about it’s fascinating and darkish. The precise reverse of darkish is Gereja Ayam in Java, higher often known as the Hen Church. It’s alleged to be a dove, however locals didn’t assume so, and the enterprise is extra a farce than a tragedy, an enormous, unusual clump of outsider artwork.

This Land Is My Land

From ‘Freedom Cove’

If there’s one utterly inspirational story within the guide, it’s that of Freedom Cove, or extra particularly artists Catherine King and Wayne Adams, who constructed a floating artwork studio that, as soon as they started to stay in it, was expanded past your wildest creativeness, however not theirs. Its a candy story of the chances created from love, artistry, and pluck. One of many variations between it and all the opposite tales and the one which makes the venture appear wholesome is that it’s the effort of two individuals on equal standing, with equal objectives, real looking and barely humble calls for of the world, and a devotion to the opposite individual, not simply themselves. And maybe that’s the lesson in one of the simplest ways to construct a workable utopia.

What Warner and Dam format in This Land Is My Land is a wealthy, amusing, and fairly thorough survey of people that take the thought of carving out a distinct segment for themselves a lot additional than nearly all of us ever go. In some instances motivational, in others preventative, it’s an excellent instance of what historical past comics can do — amuse and inform grown-ups, and for teenagers, perhaps assist construct a workable bullshit meter to keep away from catastrophe and swindle, but in addition perhaps instill the sense that they don’t essentially need to do issues like society suggests. There are different paths.

John Seven is a journalist and youngsters’s guide author dwelling in North Adams, Massachusetts. His books embrace ‘A Rule Is To Break: A Baby’s Information To Anarchy,’ ‘Completely satisfied Punks 1-2-Three,’ ‘Frankie Appreciated To Sing,’ and others. Discover out about all his issues at

About the author